Art, Beliefs, and the Supreme Court

September 2022
The Conversation

Art, Beliefs, and the Supreme Court

Introduction

Dive into the heart of a heated debate reaching the Supreme Court on December 5, 2022! At the center is a wedding website designer who, citing her Christian beliefs, refuses to create sites for same-sex couples. This clash between free speech and anti-discrimination laws has everyone asking: Can the government compel artists to create messages against their conscience? Previously, the Court tackled a similar issue with a baker, but now it's graphic artist Lorie Smith's turn. With the justices hinting at a strict scrutiny approach, this case might just set a groundbreaking precedent. Curious about the collision of freedom, faith, and rights? The Conversation has the full scoop!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Why It Matters

Discover how this topic shapes your world and future

Rights at the Crossroads - When Freedom Speaks for Itself

Imagine living in a world where what you say, create, or believe could land you in a courtroom. This is not a distant reality but a present-day scenario that involves a simmering pot of rights, beliefs, and laws all clashing together. The case of a wedding website designer refusing to create for a same-sex couple based on her beliefs brings to light the delicate balance between freedom of speech and anti-discrimination laws. This isn't just about a website; it's about how societies decide what is more important - the right to express oneself freely or the right to live free from discrimination. For you, this could mean understanding the world you're inheriting, where the lines between personal beliefs and public rights are constantly being redrawn. This topic isn't just relevant; it's a mirror reflecting the ongoing debates in your community, schools, and possibly within yourself about fairness, equality, and freedom.

Speak like a Scholar

border-left-bar-item

First Amendment

A part of the U.S. Constitution that protects freedoms, including speech, religion, press, assembly, and the right to petition the government.

border-left-bar-item

Compelled speech

Being forced to express messages or adopt ideas against one’s will, considered a violation of the First Amendment.

border-left-bar-item

Anti-discrimination laws

Regulations that prohibit unfair treatment of individuals based on certain characteristics, such as race, gender, sexual orientation, and religion.

border-left-bar-item

Strict scrutiny

The highest level of judicial review used by courts to evaluate the constitutionality of laws, requiring a law to be necessary to achieve a compelling governmental interest.

border-left-bar-item

Public accommodation laws

Laws that require businesses and other entities to provide services to the public without discrimination.

border-left-bar-item

Free exercise clause

Part of the First Amendment that protects individuals' rights to practice their religion freely, without government interference.

Independent Research Ideas

border-left-bar-item

Comparative analysis of anti-discrimination laws globally

Investigate how different countries balance freedom of speech with anti-discrimination efforts, providing insights into cultural and legal differences.

border-left-bar-item

The psychology of belief and bias in legal decisions

Explore how personal beliefs and biases of individuals, including judges, might influence legal decisions on cases involving freedom of speech and discrimination.

border-left-bar-item

The impact of social media on freedom of speech and hate speech legislation

Examine how the rise of social media platforms has affected the legal boundaries of free speech and efforts to combat online discrimination.

border-left-bar-item

Artistic expression vs. legal obligations

Delve into cases where artists' rights to freedom of expression clash with legal or societal expectations to not discriminate, highlighting the tension between creativity and equality.

border-left-bar-item

The role of religion in shaping laws on freedom of speech and discrimination

Analyze how religious beliefs have historically influenced laws regarding freedom of speech and anti-discrimination, and how this relationship is evolving in a secularizing world.